Head to Head: Battle of the Caffeine Drinks

Wake up with coffee or an energy drink?

October 18, 2022

It doesn’t seem to be enough hours in the day to be productive and sleep enough. Because of this, many people run on some form of caffeine to make it through their days. People’s pick varies with their tastes and likes, but also the supposed effectiveness of keeping them awake.

Staff Writer McKayle McGoldrick and Sports Editor Chelsea Rodriguez debate the better caffeinated drink to get through the day.

Energy Drinks; The Best Caffeine Source

Monster+energy+drinks+stocked+up.

Photo McKayle McGoldrick

Monster energy drinks stocked up.

Recently, coffee and energy drinks have been 50/50 in popularity for caffeine enjoyers. Compared to coffee, energy drinks are absolutely the most sensible choice of caffeine hands down.

To start off, any type of coffee takes time to prepare even if you’re simply making “normal” instant coffee with cream and sugar. I prefer to forgo the hassle of making it myself, or breaking the bank at Starbucks, for the convenience of an energy drink.

Coffee doesn’t give you the quick, easy caffeination as a single can of an energy drink will; if you’re a real caffeine fiend, one iced coffee simply won’t cut it. The average amount of caffeine in a small cup of coffee is 94mg, comparing that to a Celsius, for example, one can has 200mg of caffeine. If you want to stay awake, energy drinks are your best friend.

There’s no comparing the flavors between coffee and an energy drink given they’re so different from each other, but energy drinks are more refreshing since they don’t feel as heavy and intense as a cup of coffee can.

The truth is (unless you’re a 60 year old who prefers plain flavorless black coffee), in order for coffee to taste remotely good, tons of sugar, creams and flavorings have to be added which, needless to say, is bad for your health if you’re a regular coffee drinker.

In terms of what’s the healthier option, there’s a common stereotype involving energy drinks that they are extremely unhealthy and will likely give you a heart attack by the age of 25. However, the truth is that the very unhealthy options like Rudbull and C4 energy drinks aren’t the only options out there. Drinks like Alani and my personal favorite, Celsius, are healthy options that can provide benefits like boosting your metabolism, vitamin C and B12 that a sugar filled iced coffee doesn’t provide.

Of course, partaking in energy drinks, like anything else, should be done in moderation. In my experience and according to Advent Health you could have symptoms like, “Anxiety, restlessness and dehydration…” if you drink too much. It’s wise to make sure you don’t drink these while dehydrated or on an empty stomach, it would put you at much lower risk for these symptoms.

Next time you’re given the option between a cup of iced coffee or an energy drink, there’s no debating: energy drinks are no doubt the way to go.

Leave a Comment

Need energy? Forget Those Drinks, Have Coffee

Cinnamon+Iced+Latte+with+a+metal+straw.

Photo Chelsea Rodriguez

Cinnamon Iced Latte with a metal straw.

You’re tired and in desperate need of a pick-me-up to get you through the day, in front of you appears a cup of coffee and an energy drink, which do you choose? Both energy drinks and coffee hold the same purpose, to administer caffeine which will improve productivity and brain function. But, when looking at them separately there is clearly a better option, coffee.

Some would say that they don’t drink coffee because it just doesn’t have the same effect as an energy drink. But that’s not true, technically speaking. In a study done by Coffee Affection, they tested multiple energy drinks and compared them to a cup of coffee. When looking at one of the leading energy drinks, “Redbull, an 8.46-ounce can hold 80 mg of caffeine whereas an 8-ounce cup of coffee holds between 70-140 mg of caffeine. “This has been proven to be true for multiple different drinks, drinking a cup of coffee actually has a stronger effect than an energy drink.

Coffee is also more cost-effective. A single packet of coffee can make up to multiple pots and depending on what you get you can make a variety of drinks with a myriad of flavors. Energy drinks are made in single servings, meaning that once you finish that can of Celsius, that’s it. One can of Celsius is about $2, you would need one for every day of the week so that’s about $14 a week for an energy drink.

Not to mention, most of them don’t even taste good. Due to all the additives and extra chemicals that they sneak into those cans, they can be bitter and spicy. Then they use flavoring to cover the taste and most of the time they’re overly sweet and tart an example would be all the cherry, orange and raspberry flavored drinks. Coffee tastes better and all coffee whether at home or in a shop can be customized, plus if you’re making it at home you actually know what’s going into your drink.

Not only is coffee more affordable, but it’s actually healthier. Coffee actually comes from a plant and if you really want to get into it black coffee has 1 calorie per 8-ounce cup. Of course when you add things like milk, sugars, creamers and syrups we start to lean into the unhealthy side of things.

Nevertheless, when compared to energy drinks they have a lot less sugar and mystery ingredients.  Energy drinks that are advertised as ‘sugar-free’ can most times have artificial sweeteners which are ‘generally safe’ but who wants to ingest something that is somewhat safe? Artificial sweeteners are also addictive and while they can satisfy your craving for a moment, they often intensify future sugar cravings. This means that you may get the energy you need from these drinks but once it wears off, you’ll ‘crash’ and be left feeling worse.

You can certainly find an energy drink that is safe for you and healthy, but when it comes down to it coffee is the better choice.

Leave a Comment

Knight Writers • Copyright 2024 • FLEX WordPress Theme by SNOLog in

Donate to Knight Writers
$1210
$1500
Contributed
Our Goal

Comments (0)

All Knight Writers' Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *